Got feedback on the new design? We're Listening! Send us Feedback

Old Media Still Needs to Get Over its Control Issues »

Posted by: cactushair 2 months, 3 weeks ago

38 Comments Report this Story

9.1

Scale of 1 to 10

Read: 23

Propped: 153

Comments: 38

Click Prop It to Raise Score
Prop it

The wonderful thing about the Internet is that nobody controls it. And if you can 't control the medium, you can't control the message. Yet industries that are used to control don't like to give it up. Old media is like that. Even in this day and age, its struggle with control issues continues.

Read Full Story at techcrunch.com

Join the Discussion

+ Add Comment
Comments So Far: 38
  • 0%
    gamahuche2 months, 3 weeks ago

    This is an excellent and well-written analysis.

    The question that it also opens up and leaves for further exploration is how the virtual/digital world can most beneficially respond to these new paradigms.

    Bookmarked!

    Reply

    1 Reply

    • 0%
      1-2-Oscar2 months, 3 weeks ago

      Au contraire, mon ami--it is garbage.

      Reply
    • 0%
      Spadecaller2 months, 3 weeks ago

      Great post cactushair!

      Ah yes, the dinosaurs (msm)are getting chilly.

      Reply
      • 0%
        unome22 months, 3 weeks ago

        Old Media tries to think for their consumers, telling us thinks like corporate war for profit is good and will protect us. New media in which the consumers participate and think for themselves realize this only produces death and hate, enriches the corporate elite, and that we can be better.

        Reply

        9 Replies

        • 0%
          Codi69342 months, 3 weeks ago

          With no control over the "New Media" we may find out that global warming is a hoax, we are at war and winning , Hillary is a socialist and Obama is clueless. There is an up side to all this.

          Reply

          8 Replies

      • 0%
        jimdoze2 months, 3 weeks ago

        It might be helpful to think of intellectual paradigms as a form of cultural DNA code. New Media sets the stage for dramatic new multiples of paradigmatic mutations. As with the biological world, most such mutations are not/will not be positive for the body politic. Some, however, will be. It is/will be interesting to watch humandkind deal with, and make choices in, the floodtide of such mutations.

        Reply

        6 Replies

        • 0%
          1-2-Oscar2 months, 3 weeks ago

          Are you prepared to make such choices? Many here seem to think that there are no prevailing standards which apply to such a decision-making process. I become very unpopular when I point out that avoiding making choices is not quite the same thing as making good (socially beneficial) choices.

          In Nature, the overwhelming majority of the "mutations" you extol are harmful to the species, and are often eliminated in a single generation. but the internet is a place where harmful mutations are replicated willy-nilly, and we are treated endlessly to conspiracy garbage until it takes on a religious cast to some. It may be beneficial to question each conclusion derived, but it is wasteful to raise the same useless question "ad infinitum."

          Reply

          5 Replies

      • 0%
        1-2-Oscar2 months, 3 weeks ago

        The proposition that "Old Media" has exercised effective thought and/or information control and that it seeks to extend such control to the internet is a pernicious fiction.

        You are controlled to precisely the extent which you permit. The biggest problem is that you accept some agents of control and vigorously defend that acceptance without questioning whether you have been given useful (and accurate) information to start with. MoveOn.org and Rupert Murdock's media empire have a lot in common. They both advance an information set for you to "believe," both have selfish motives in doing so, and neither gives a damn whether you will benefit.

        Reply

        1 Reply

        • 0%
          Leemck022 months, 3 weeks ago

          1-2-Oscar, I have to disagree. All that money invested in marketing is for a reason. If you ever take a formal sales course that will also change your mind. I know for a fact, an organization that has been taking data on from individuals for a couple of decades, their survey gives them feedback; the goal is so they won't invest a lot of money in someone who is not cut out for the task. They can tell you all about yourself for your test results. I had a sales person who came to my house pushing those loans. If I didn't have a background that allowed me to see the path to a close, I may have gotten on board as well. The 'extent you permit' sounds good, but training is a powerful advantage over the untrained. The matter of questioning is very valid, but this stuff is subtle. Out of the clear blue, NBC's Today Show took time to inform us that Oprah's popularity is slipping. I never watch the show but I wonder where that came from? Are we approaching the General election?

          Reply
        • 0%
          Endoscopy2 months, 3 weeks ago

          The dinosaur media is very left wing and dying. ABC, NBC, CBS, NYT, etc. Their news as very far to the left. That angers a large segment of the population. It is why FOX has come on strong along with talk radio. Air America is just hanging on. Where there is competition for ratings and buying a paper these institutions are having great problems if they are one sided.

          The web allows complete freedom of expressing any point of view. This site for example has people of everypolitical persuasion that can say how they think and feel about a wide range of issues.

          Reply

          2 Replies

          • 0%
            ETproductions2 months, 3 weeks ago

            Right wing propaganda. The MSM is now the exclusive property of VERY big businesses. Their agenda is slanted towards corporatocracy.

            Reply

            1 Reply

        • 0%
          SunnyDays2 months, 3 weeks ago

          Hmmmn.. old or current, media is really powerful.

          Reply
          • 0%
            tester2 months, 3 weeks ago

            wow, i like analyzes like that. thank you

            Reply
            • 0%
              Simon_Slade2 months, 3 weeks ago

              the fact that the internet has no editing or control mechanism can be very misleading and destructive, in some cases. As much as I love new media for the most part, there are some downsides to it.

              Reply

              2 Replies

              • 0%
                crghss2 months, 3 weeks ago

                The spread of radical Islam is one.

                Reply

                1 Reply

            • 0%
              Charlson2 months, 3 weeks ago

              MSM has long ago abdicated their responsiblity to report the news towards entertaining their viewers with the news. That was the beginning of the end for news respectability.

              Reply
              • 0%
                cleare2 months, 3 weeks ago

                part of the control issues of "old media" assures accuracy in reporting...there are no such assurances in cyberspace.

                as always, it is best to consider "the source".

                Reply

                4 Replies

                • 0%
                  crghss2 months, 3 weeks ago

                  Nutscape is a prime example of this.

                  Reply

                  1 Reply

                • 0%
                  Leemck022 months, 3 weeks ago

                  Cleare, the assumption of accuracy is the greatest deception. I offer you to consider our government established a 'Disinformation Agency' because of that sort of thinking. Agents as moles could attend our universities or get positions of note and publish in Time, Wall Street and others with misleading studies or articles that promoted sympathy to causes not in America's best interest very effectively. What you hear or don't as a matter of timing is a factor. What's the point of McCain and Bush taking pictures? Images, people want your mind; where it goes, your butt will follow.

                  Reply

                  1 Reply

              • 0%
                ETproductions2 months, 3 weeks ago

                Lou Dobbs tonight had a coterie of his sycophants on to help him reply to Obama's speech targeted at the Dobbs' inspiration of hatred of immigrants and linking it to spike in attacks on Hispanics.

                One of the talking heads actually said that Obama should be smarter than to pick a fight with the guy who owns the microphone. Yes, they still think they own the only microphone there is.

                Reply
                • 0%
                  Leemck022 months, 3 weeks ago

                  The media, the Fourth Estate, given Constitutional protection for free speech. It's up there with the Executive, Legislative and Judicial branches in concept of democracy. It sucks, with the propaganda. It's not always about lies or truth but deception. Someone to tell the facts but they lead the public astray. Media play got us in Iraq, to accept Katrina, to do little with an election suspect of fraud, 8 Billion in cash from the Treasury missing with not more than a whimper, Enron; you know the list. We get this Conservative and Liberal label, left and right wing on issues but not the prospective so we know exactly what happened and who done it. Why is it that I can hear a speech on C-Span for myself and get a totally different account from the media elsewhere; who don't tell the news but specialize in spin? Need I say more? Vote for change.

                  Reply
                  Next 25 comments

                  You must be signed in to post a comment. Sign in »

                  Submitted By:
                  cactushair

                  Hello)))

                  Also submitted:

                  Related Articles:

                  Why not submit a story?

                  Also Propping This Article

                  view all »

                  Groups Watching This

                  No groups are watching this story. Why not share it with your group?

                  Advertisement